TINA SRISVASTAVA: OK, so when we were talking about radar,
we had a great reminder about how the origins of that
came right here at MIT.
And in fact, physically right here,
where the Stata building is located.
Well, when we're talking about instrument flying,
there is also a very strong connection here to MIT.
So does anyone know the story of Jimmy Dolittle
and his first blind flight?
Yes, do you want to share?
AUDIENCE: [INAUDIBLE]
TINA SRISVASTAVA: Yes, you're right.
He has a lot of good stories.
AUDIENCE: Takeoff and landing [? just on ?]
flight instruments.
TINA SRISVASTAVA: Takeoff and landing
just on flight instruments, yes.
Good, that's exactly right.
AUDIENCE: He also got a doctorate here.
TINA SRISVASTAVA: He also got his doctorate here,
that's right.
You have a good understanding of him.
AUDIENCE: [INAUDIBLE]
TINA SRISVASTAVA: So Jimmy Dolittle,
before he came to MIT, was flying in the military.
And he was doing a lot of things.
He's known for flying across the country in a very short period
of time and encountering a lot of storms and weather.
And being one of the first people to really rely
on the instruments inside your planes--
all your flight controls--
when you're not able to look outside the airplane.
And just as you said, he studied here
and got his graduate degree here.
But even after that, he continued
to study how a pilot could fly when
the visibility outside the airplane was very difficult--
and really pioneered the concept that in a very foggy weather
condition, for example, you can still successfully
fly an airplane by relying on the flight instruments.
And in particular, one of the most significant flight
instruments is what's called an artificial horizon.
So Philip already introduced that flight instrument.
We'll talk about it.
And when we've discussed the six-pack, where
you have these six circle flight instruments,
it's the one in the middle on the top.
And we'll look in that in particular.
So that artificial horizon with a little airplane on it
is basically supposed to replace looking outside your windshield
and seeing the real horizon.
And so it's a good thing to rely on.
One of the most important instruments when you're flying.
So basically, instrument flying is
how you can rely on the technologies
inside your airplane to avoid hitting things
and to land without being able to see outside your airplane.
And IFR stands for Instrument Flight Rules.
And so that means that you have to follow a set of rules
when there are clouds outside.
Now, because pilots really need to make
sure to practice and stay current,
we have a situation where most of the time that people
are practicing that instrument flights
might be a condition where actually it is quite
sunny and beautiful outside.
But they're just practicing.
So the way that we distinguish it
is when it's actually very foggy, very cloudy,
you can't see outside--
that is described by IMC, or Instrument Meteorological
Conditions--
IMC conditions.
So that's when you actually have the condition where
you can't see outside the airplane
and then you follow your IFR, your Instrument Flight Rules.
And so the goal of this whole process
is to be able to fly safely, even when
you can't see out the window.
So why would you want to be flying when you
can't see outside the window?
There are a lot of reasons for that.
I've been spending a lot of time in California.
And here's a familiar sight in California.
If you see a lot of clouds, a lot of fog--
fog is a daily occurrence, depending
on where you are, especially in the San Francisco Bay Area.
And so a VFR pilot won't be able to really
fly in those conditions at all.
PHILIP GREENSPUN: It's important to remember,
it's beautiful right above the fog.
So you could be flying in the clouds for a minute
and then you proceed to your destination in the desert
or wherever it is.
TINA SRISVASTAVA: Absolutely.
So Philip was just talking about a condition just shown
in this picture here, where it might
be the case that there's a thin layer of clouds
or fog at a low altitude.
But if you were to go through that, above it,
it's really beautiful up above the clouds.
And sometimes this is called VFR On Top.
So you have Visual Flight Rules up on top of the clouds.
It's not that you're flying in the clouds,
but you have a cloud cover below you.
And so if you have your instrument flight rating,
then you can fly right through that thin layer
of clouds or fog and be flying in a beautiful day above that.
I'd also like to point out that instrument flying makes
you a better pilot.
So I know this personally-- if you remember from yesterday,
I talked about how after my private,
basically one of the first things I did
was start on my instrument flight rating.
And you actually start with just learning
how to be a better pilot.
You start sticking to your altitude a little better.
When you're a VFR pilot, a lot of times
when we talked about the different airspace,
there isn't a very strict restriction on what altitude
you need to be at.
You're not really filing a flight plan.
You could be changing your heading
and wandering over one way and wandering over another way.
But when you start training for your instrument,
you start learning more precisely what it takes
to trim your aircraft's configuration correctly,
how to stay at 3,000 feet, 1-8-0 heading, whatever it is--
and actually maintain that while you're
doing a number of other operations in your plane.
And not getting distracted in such a way
that causes you to change your heading or your altitude.
So that just makes you a better pilot altogether,
even in visual flight conditions.
The reason, of course, that you have to learn how to fly more
precisely is because when you are in an actual IMC
condition with clouds and you can't
see outside your airplane, you're
relying on the air traffic controllers
to sequence the airplanes and make sure they
don't come near each other.
And so the air traffic controller
is going to want to know that if they
tell you to stay on a particular vector-- so an altitude
heading.
And they want to make sure you actually stay there,
because if you start drifting off-course,
you could drift into the course of another airplane
that they have flying in a different direction.
So you actually are required to do
some amount of instrument training,
even for your private pilot--
about three hours.
So that means that you have to go flying
and rely purely on the instruments in order to fly.
So it would be great if there is a day that
has fog without an adverse weather situation
so you could actually fly in true IMC conditions,
where your instructor is really taking control there
but allowing you to experience it.
But if that doesn't happen, you can use a view-limiting device,
such as foggles.
So these are basically glasses you put on
that fog out where you would see outside the window and only
are visible looking at your controls.
Or a hood that basically blocks your view of everything
except the instruments.
So we've already talked about radar and ATC
and working with those air traffic controllers.
So those air traffic controllers are
responsible for the separation of the airplanes.
And they will assign specific altitudes, headings,
and different routes and clearances.
Navaids is short for navigational aids,
like radio and GPS.
And then we've already discussed just now about a transponder.
So that xpdr just stands for transponder.
And that's just basically saying that if the radar itself
is unable to provide the accurate altitude of the plane,
you can add on the transponder to help with the radar return.
We've also discussed briefly the ADS-B--
and we will get into, when we talk about weather data,
how you can build your own device to receive
that ADS-B data.
So let's talk about the different phases of an IFR
flight.
So there's a little bit more you need to do
in the flight planning stage.
You also do need to file a flight plan,
which we discussed isn't required for your VFR flights.
And then some more things you need
to do once you depart, when you're en route,
and then your approach to landing.
So what Philip helped me pass out
are what's called approach plates.
So you'll hear that--
so it's different information that talks about--
when you're landing, they're different specific procedures.
Because, again, you can't see outside the airplane,
so they will create a path that you fly on that
are specifically designed to avoid terrain and allow
you to come in and land at the airport safely.
Although I passed out the physical piece of paper--
and a lot of people have physical pieces of paper
for those approach plates--
I've also pulled up an airport.
I used Bedford, my local airport.
And you can go down on ForeFlight
to approach and see all the different approach procedures.
So I'll pass this around.
And basically you can click on different approach procedures.
PHILIP GREENSPUN: Let me also add that all these plates are
available free online.
If you go to any source, like SkyVector or AirNav.com,
you can go to the airport and see a list of the procedures
and just grab the PDF on your device.
TINA SRISVASTAVA: Absolutely.
They're all free online.
And you want to make sure you have the updated ones,
because sometimes they do change.
PHILIP GREENSPUN: Yeah, I meant just here for the lecture.
If you just want to have it in front of you on your phone.
TINA SRISVASTAVA: Yeah, absolutely.
Pre-flight planning is just really important.
As much as we just talked about meteorology and different
adverse weather conditions-- so just
because you have the ability to fly in the clouds doesn't mean
it's a good idea.
If there is anything like thunderstorms,
icing conditions, something that could impair your ability
to fly safely, then it doesn't mean you should go flying.
And it's really important to understand
where all the adverse conditions are and look at all that data.
So when you're doing your pre-flight planning,
there's certain information about when
you need to have an alternate.
So the time and hour before--
an hour after your estimated time of arrival.
Your ceiling-- so what's a ceiling again?
That's when you have cloud cover--
so either broken or overcast clouds.
So they're saying if that ceiling
is less than 2,000 feet.
And then your visibility-- so how far out you can see--
three miles.
And one of the biggest rules of thumb to keep in mind
is that when you're doing this planning,
you don't want a situation where you take off from an airport
and you plan it such that the weather is
going to get so bad that you can't return to that airport.
So a good, safe rule of thumb is make sure
that you can get back to the airport you're taking off from,
in case there's any issue with your airplane or travel.
You want to be able to safely get back
from where you took off from.
And even though with your IFR rating,
you can fly through clouds, there
are still specific visibility requirements
for every single approach and airport
that you're coming into.
It can't be a completely dense fog all the way to the ground.
There is a altitude where even the big, major commercial
jets have to be able to identify certain runway indicators
before they're allowed to land.
And if they're not able to, they have
to go around or find an alternate airport.
And all that specific information
is on those approach plates that we'll talk about in a moment.
So you can actually file a flight plan directly
on the computer or with an app, such as ForeFlight.
This is what I was discussing a moment ago.
This is your six-pack, again--
your flight controls.
And the one right in the center at the top
is that artificial horizon.
And just as Jimmy Dolittle did--
found that as a very important reference point.
That's really what you want to spend
most of your time looking at when
you're flying the instrument.
Just like when you're flying VFR,
you want to spend most of your time looking out
the window at the actual horizon and what's out there.
You want to look at this to make sure you haven't started
turning and not realized it.
So we're going to get into human factors this afternoon.
But just like we talked about when we were discussing
aerodynamics, your body can't really
feel the difference between gravity and acceleration.
And so if you start a turn but then you basically
have even doubt in your flying level,
your body will not notice that you're tilted.
And so that's why it's really important
to keep an eye on this artificial horizon
and make sure you're in fact flying straight
and level when you think you are.
So we're going to talk about a lot of different safety
considerations.
We talk a lot about minimums with regard
to what are the FAA regulations or your flight
school might impose--
the place you're renting your aircraft might impose.
Certain minimums-- that they don't
want you to take the plane unless the ceiling is
above 2,000 feet, for example.
But there is also this concept of personal minimums.
And Philip and I will spend a chunk of time
at the end of the course talking about our personal minimums
and sharing them with you, that you
might want to set your own restrictions-- that, hey,
if certain things are occurring and you don't feel comfortable,
you don't think it's safe, you set
those restrictions to yourself.
So that way, on a particular day that you're planning to fly,
you don't get the get-there-itis, where you just
really want to go and you decide you're
going to do whatever it takes.
You can refer to your personal minimums and say, hey,
I have previously decided that this wasn't a good idea.
So let's stick to my judgment at that time and not fly.
We're also going to discuss how, even though the FAA might
require only a single pilot in command,
you can actually have a different person sitting next
to you, whether they're a pilot, whether they're just a friend,
you can put that person to work to help you out
in managing your cockpit and helping with some
of the navigation, for example.
So let's talk a little bit about the approach plate.
So does everybody have an approach plate,
either on their computer or a physical piece of paper?
Is anyone missing one?
OK, so there's a lot of information
on an approach plate.
And you don't need to know any of this for your private pilot.
But just so you get oriented, I'm
just going to give you a high level of what kind
of information is on this approach plate
and what we're talking about.
So again, this is a situation where
there could be cloud cover or you're flying in fog
and so you can't see outside your airplane
or you can't see the airport, but you
have to safely arrive at the airport.
So the approach plate provides a flight path for you
to fly on to safely enter the airport's vicinity,
enter the final approach, and then to a point where
you can visually identify certain runway markings
and land safely.
So the very top of the approach plate
tells you a lot of information.
So the top right corner, where it says RNAV GPS--
that's identifying the type of approach that it is.
So usually, it'll tell you whether it's
a precision approach or a non-precision approach.
So there are different types of instruments on your plane.
You'll see, as that iPad's being passed around,
with the different ones you can click on-- there
are certain instruments in your plane
and at the airport that will tell you how you can land.
So an ILS, for example--
an Instrument Landing System.
If that is available, it can be a very precise way
to land at an airport, whereas if you don't have exactly
those things available, you might use a GPS or a VOR,
which are different types of approaches you can fly.
It'll also tell you the runway, which is very important.
Runway 16-- so that's the runway you're trying to land at.
And then just below it is the airport.
So this one in particular is Port Smith,
which is an airport that's basically--
if you drive to the coast from here.
So it's at the border between Maine and New Hampshire,
right along the coastline.
And people refer to this airport as Pease.
You also see a lot of very specific information-- a lot
of numbers and things there.
So we've discussed a few times the concept of ADAS.
So you see that ADAS-- so that's the frequency you can dial into
to get the weather information at that airport.
And you'll need to get the latest weather
information before you enter and start doing the procedure.
You also see the air traffic controller here
is Boston approach, who you'll be talking to on 125.05.
You see the Pease tower, or Portsmouth tower--
128.4.
And then after you land, here's the ground controller
that you talk to.
PHILIP GREENSPUN: Tina, do we have to worry
about those other numbers?
Like 269?
TINA SRISVASTAVA: Let's make it simple
and say, no, you don't have to worry
about those other numbers.
PHILIP GREENSPUN: OK, those are for the military.
That's UHF.
And you won't have that in your rental Piper.
TINA SRISVASTAVA: Another really important thing
to pay attention to is at the top right corner
is a missed approach.
So if you were not able to complete the landing--
maybe you had to go around or something didn't feel safe
or you lost communications when you were coming in--
and you are not able to execute the landing,
then you fly a missed approach.
So it tells you what to do if you weren't able to land.
So it says climb to 3,000-- so 3,000 feet--
direct-- and it says this TTATT is the name
of a particular location.
So, TTATT.
And then it says, and on track 165 degrees--
so that's the heading--
to IDEED and hold.
So it basically says that if you weren't able to land,
then you're supposed to continue straight, climb to 3,000 feet,
to this TTATT location.
And then on the track 165 degrees,
to continue on to IDEED and hold.
So now the middle of the approach plate
really tells you what to do.
There a couple different points that are really interesting.
So IAF-- does anyone know what IAF stands for?
AUDIENCE: [INAUDIBLE] Approach Fix.
TINA SRISVASTAVA: Initial Approach Fix.
So these are places where you can enter this pattern.
So IAF-- you can enter here at ITAWT.
There are a couple others here as well.
So what it's saying is if you entered here at ITAWT,
you're flying at 3,000 feet on heading
118 degrees to this holding pattern right here.
And every time it has these weird letters
is representing another point.
And then you continue straight towards the airport,
to this other spot.
And then here is the actual airport--
it says runway 16, where you could land right here.
And if you have a missed approach,
remember it said to continue straight to TTATT
and then to continue on to IDEED and you can do a hold over
here.
So aviators are not without a sense of humor.
So let's just go through what that would be.
What are the names of the points along the way?
You start with ITAWT, ITAWA, PUDYE, TTATT--
IDEED.
So I'm getting a lot of chuckles.
In case you missed that, it's I thought I saw a putty-tat.
I did, I did see a putty-tat.
Anyway, good cartoon for you there.
So that shows you a little bit of humor
in this particular approach plate.
The bottom of the approach plate shows the same thing,
but a profile view.
So this shows the altitudes as you're going.
So you start at 3,000.
This is your heading, you're going along into ITAWA.
And then you go down, you're descending to PUDYE.
And then all the way here, where you land.
And if you have to execute a missed approach,
then it pictorially describes that missed approach, which
is you continue straight at 3,000 feet,
climb to 3,000 to TTATT and then on heading 165 to IDEED.
And then here on the left, of course,
is a picture of that runway.
And it tells you what the runway looks like,
the taxiways around it, the length
of the runway, et cetera.
PHILIP GREENSPUN: What are the minimums?
How low can you go before seeing the runway?
TINA SRISVASTAVA: The minimums depend on the type of aircraft
that you have.
I was skipping over it because it's fairly complicated.
But this whole thing down here basically
indicates the minimums in terms of your visibility
as you're landing.
So where it says category, it's the different types
of categories of aircraft.
Circling means that if you were planning to land at one runway,
but you circle to land at another runway.
And then it has a lot of specifics depending
on the actual type of aircraft.
PHILIP GREENSPUN: What about in a CIRRUS?
A modern CIRRUS?
TINA SRISVASTAVA: You can go ahead, Philip.
PHILIP GREENSPUN: OK.
So that top one is LPV.
That's essentially a precision approach using the GPS.
So if you have a WAAS GPS, which is the modern kind,
as of about 10 years ago, you can go down to 300 feet.
So if you don't see some indication of the airport
environment, the runway leaving lights or something,
then you can't go below 300 feet.
It is time to do a missed.
And it also tells you you need 2,400 feet of visibility.
TINA SRISVASTAVA: In this case, that 300 feet
is regardless of the category, whether it's a, b, c, d, or e--
they all show that same amount.
And when Philip is talking about depending on the type--
whether you're reading here the LPV, LNAV, et cetera,
on the left.
PHILIP GREENSPUN: Yeah, like the LNAV approach down there,
towards the bottom, that would be for an older non-WAAS GPS.
TINA SRISVASTAVA: So there's obviously
a lot more information on this approach plate.
But those are some of the key highlights so you don't
get afraid when you see these.
Any questions before we move past this topic?
Yes.
AUDIENCE: This is a stupid question,
but I've actually looked at this approach plate before
and I didn't get that joke.
Is there somewhere you can look up why they named them
what they are?
Or who named them?
TINA SRISVASTAVA: Oh yeah, that's a good question.
So basically, if you missed the joke--
the I taught I taw a puddy-tat joke.
Is there a place you can look it up?
I'm not sure.
But I know a couple of people that
write different articles about aviation.
It'd be a good exercise to see if we can Google and find
a couple of those articles and share where they figure out
how they name all these different points.
OK, so if you want to learn--
yes, go ahead.
AUDIENCE: What are the speeds?
TINA SRISVASTAVA: The speeds.
Yeah, absolutely-- so what speed do
you have to be as you're flying these different approaches?
Do you want to tackle it?
PHILIP GREENSPUN: Yeah, I'll just talk about that.
If you're in a really busy airport,
they may tell you to keep your speed up so that you don't
clog up the works for the jet.
And also autopilots don't work that well
if you're going really slowly.
So it's probably conventional in something like a CIRRUS
to be going around 120 knots before you
get to the final approach fix.
You're going to put in one notch of flaps just before.
And 120 knots is the limitation on an older CIRRUS, for flaps.
So you'll slow down to maybe 105 as you're
going down the glide slope.
And then once you break out of the clouds--
let's say at 500 feet above the runway--
although, the minimum there was 300 above sea level, which
is 200 feet above the runway.
You put in the full flaps and you'll
slow down to your final approach speed of 75 or 80 knots.
So those would be the typical speeds on a precision approach.
TINA SRISVASTAVA: And if you're practicing, you're new,
it's OK to go a little slower.
They'll tell you if there are other people behind you.
Holds are a good time--
the whole point is to basically take time and slow down.
They're trying to get you to wait for some reason.
So you might want to go 90 knots.
The reason you don't want to go much below that
is, of course, you are doing so many things in the airplane
to get prepared for the approach,
you don't want to get down into very slow air speeds
where you could stall as well.
That could be a big issue.
So now just talking about how you go on
to get your instrument flight rating.
There's some good resources here to point out.
And this talks a little bit about the time--
that XC just stands for Cross-Country Time.
Then you actually need time and in actual IMC conditions
or in simulated.
So that's where you're wearing your goggles
or your foggles or your hood.
And again, you can actually do a little bit of simulated flight
training as well.
So some places have a red bird simulator
or other types of simulator where you can
do some simulated flight time.
Sometimes that'll save you a little bit
of money, because you don't have to spend the engine
hours to fly out to wherever you're doing the approach.
And you can just restart very quickly.
So there could be some advantages of that.
And then, Philip, you have some advice here
on how you get your IFR rating.
PHILIP GREENSPUN: Yeah, I think if you're going to do this--
once you finish your private-- these higher performance
airplanes aren't great for training.
The little Pipers and Cessnas are probably better,
just because they're slower.
But as soon as you're going to work on the instrument rating
and do transportation, then it's time to get into the CIRRUS
or get into the Bonanza that you're intending to use
for family transportation.
Time and type and realistic-- going with an instructor
on the trips that you're actually going to do--
is invaluable for safety.
I think one good way to do it is do a big cross-country trip
with an instructor.
Or just go to Florida, go to California, go to Alaska.
And do an approach every hour.
So then you go through a lot of weather systems
and you get very comfortable with getting the weather
information, filing flight plans, working with controllers
in different situations.
TINA SRISVASTAVA: One other thing I would add--
it's a cool trick you might not have heard of.
So whenever you're getting an instruction,
you have to pay not only for the aircraft rental,
but for the time of your instructor.
Well, if you take an instrument flight and you practice
an approach and then you just want to practice it a couple
of times yourself, you can actually go up without
your instructor-- without any view-limiting devices,
of course--
where you can fully look outside the airplane.
And you can keep flying that same approach.
So you can actually fly practice approaches
without actually being in an instrument condition
or with view-limiting devices, to just practice the mechanics
of the whole thing.
How you deal with airspeed, who's
going to start talking to you next,
what do you need to do next.
And I find that to be very useful.
You'll also find on that--
you heard from Sebastian yesterday
about the MIT Flying Club.
So there's an email list-- flying-pilots@mit.edu.
So once you become a pilot, it's great to be on that list
because instrument-rated pilots have to keep
practicing their approaches.
And so they need somebody to sit next to them
to look out the airplane for other aircraft
while they're wearing their view-limiting devices.
And that person is called a safety pilot.
So as long as you have your private pilot license,
even if you don't have your instrument rating,
you can serve as a safety pilot.
So it's a great way--
and cheap way-- to get a lot of practice
in and see an instrument pilot at work
trying to do an approach.
And you can sit there and learn and look out.
PHILIP GREENSPUN: And you get to log that time as safety pilot,
as if you had been flying.
So it's a good way to build up flying experience.
TINA SRISVASTAVA: Yeah, highly recommended.
PHILIP GREENSPUN: Here's a question for you guys.
So the safety pilot-- you heard about
the medical certification.
Let's say the person practicing the approach
has a first class medical.
So they're very healthy and the FAA
thinks the pilot is unlikely to have a heart attack and keel
over while under the hood.
Does the safety pilot need to have a current medical
to serve as safety pilot?
What do you guys think?
AUDIENCE: Yes.
PHILIP GREENSPUN: It's ridiculous.
That person has a heart attack, the regular pilot
can just take off the hood and fly.
The safety pilot shouldn't need a medical, right?
As long as their last words are, you have the controls.
But in fact, the safety pilot is a required crew member
for that operation.
So the Feds say that he or she must have a current medical.
TINA SRISVASTAVA: And just that joke
that Philip said about-- you have the controls.
I'll just take a moment to explain
what he's talking about.
When you hand over control, you take the controls,
it's important to have what's called a positive exchange
of controls.
So if I'm flying the airplane and I'm
giving the controls to Philip, I'll say, you have controls.
PHILIP GREENSPUN: I have the controls.
TINA SRISVASTAVA: You have controls.
So that reconfirming-- make sure that you
know who's flying the airplane so
that you don't result in a situation
where no one's flying.
Yes.
AUDIENCE: When do your hands come off
the controls in that exchange?
TINA SRISVASTAVA: I usually keep them
on up until I really know that he knows what he's doing.
So I actually keep it on a little bit
longer to make sure he knows and he doesn't start turning
in some other direction.
PHILIP GREENSPUN: I think on that third one.
TINA SRISVASTAVA: The final, "You have controls."
PHILIP GREENSPUN: Especially important in a helicopter.
TINA SRISVASTAVA: That's when you let go.
PHILIP GREENSPUN: The good thing about airplanes
is you can take your hands off and the airplane just keeps
doing whatever it was doing.
But the helicopter is inherently unstable.
So yeah, it's important that you don't take your hands off
until you hear that third acknowledgment.
TINA SRISVASTAVA: Yes.
AUDIENCE: How long does a cross-country trip
take, from here to California?
TINA SRISVASTAVA: So the question
was how long does it take to fly from here to California?
The answer really depends on which type of aircraft
you're flying.
So a little Cessna 172 would take a long time,
because it basically is twice as fast as a car.
And it's as the crow flies.
But if you're flying a fancy CIRRUS,
you can get much faster.
PHILIP GREENSPUN: You get a headwind going west, generally.
So it's probably going to take about 15 hours
to get to California, maybe a little over 20
in a Cessna or a Piper.
And then you'll get a little speed boost on the way back.
There are various companies that offer 10 day instrument
ratings.
And they fly around a lot.
So a couple of weeks to get to California and back
is reasonably comfortable while doing flight training
along the way.
TINA SRISVASTAVA: One of the biggest things that'll
slow you down is not how fast your plane can fly,
but also your own fatigue, which we'll
talk about in human factors.
All right are there any more questions
on instrument flight or instrument
meteorological conditions?
Yes.
AUDIENCE: What's your opinion on the steam
gauge versus the glass cockpit for [INAUDIBLE]??
TINA SRISVASTAVA: So the question
was what's our opinion on steam gauge versus a glass cockpit?
I think we know Philip's opinion here.
I've actually flown both.
I think that with the G1000, or glass cockpit, what's nice
is you can load the approach and it'll actually
show the full flight plan that you're supposed
to fly for a given approach.
And you can actually have a whole flight plan
where you have multiple approaches, one
after the other.
And it puts it up there and it makes it very easy.
But I will say that to learn it--
I've actually done instrument training
on both the steam gauge and the glass cockpit.
And I think that steam gauge obviously keeps you
on your toes a lot more.
You really know what's happening.
You're using your heading bug to do
a lot more, because you can't enter some
of these things in advance.
And so I think it's really helpful
to learn how to do that, just like I think, for example,
your autopilot is amazing.
You should have an autopilot if you're going
to fly across the country.
But you shouldn't use your autopilot
when you're doing flight training,
because the first thing Mark Nathanson, the FAA
examiner will do, will be, oh, look, your autopilot died.
Now you have to learn how to fly without it.
So I think for flight training, I recommend both.
The other reason I continue to fly both steam gauge and G1000
is that I fly with a lot of other friends.
So we talked about the MIT Flying Club,
you fly with your peers.
There's also a group of women pilots--
we call ourselves The Women Pilots of New England.
We basically bumped into each other
in the parking lots of airports and now get together.
We're actually having a dinner tonight at 6:00 PM,
so if any women pilots want to join, please do.
PHILIP GREENSPUN: Or pilots who identify as women.
TINA SRISVASTAVA: Sure.
And these groups that you fly with on these fly-outs,
it's often the case that you want
to have two pilots flying in a given airplane.
And one flies there.
And one's PIC there and one's PIC on the way back.
And so if you have a lot of friends
that fly the steam gauges, which are cheaper to rent,
you want to make sure you're current in that airplane
if you want to fly with them.
And if you fly a G1000, you want to make sure your friends
that you fly with also fly G1000s.
So I fly both, because I have friends that fly both.
And we want to make sure that we can fly together
on these fly-outs.
PHILIP GREENSPUN: Yeah, so despite the fact that I usually
fly glass cockpit aircraft, I do fly instrument approaches
in R44 helicopter instrument trainers.
And those are more challenging, because there's no autopilot.
And the machine is inherently much less stable
than the airplane.
So that's steam gauges.
So I wouldn't say there's a big difference.
Really, the world of instrument flying--
if you transfer your skills from the visual flying
world to the instrument world-- and they do transfer very well.
When you're flying visually, you're spending about 80%,
90% of your time looking out the window at the natural horizon.
When you transfer that to instrument,
you're spending 80% or 90% of your time
looking at the artificial horizon, or attitude indicator.
And if you hold a constant attitude,
the rest of the instruments take care of themselves.
The experienced instrument instructors
will often cover up all five of the other instruments, which
gets a little harder from the glass cockpit--
a lot of Post-Its.
And have the IFR student try to hold the constant attitude
as best they can.
And then remove the Post-Its after, say, two minutes.
And you'll find that you've only gained a couple hundred feet
and you've only lost maybe 10 degrees of heading.
The FAA has terrible advice about how
to be an instrument pilot.
They say scan the six-pack.
So spend, essentially, one sixth of the time.
You used to spend 90% of your time looking at the attitude
indicator?
Now, let's spend 1/6 of your time.
Or spend half of your time-- look at the attitude indicator,
look at these other things.
But if you actually study high-time instrument pilots
or jet pilots, you'll find that they're really
focusing on the attitude indicator 80%, 90% of the time,
like I said.
And if they don't do that--
I actually once flew with a guy.
He was an MIT grad--
he was an MIT PhD.
The FAA told him to scan like this, so he does.
And that airplane was all over the sky,
but he was constantly recorrecting it.
And he was right within the ACS standards
of about plus or minus 100 feet and--
I don't know, maybe it's 10 degrees of heading.
But we were in actual conditions a Piper Arrow
with pretty limited backup facilities.
So that was truly terrifying, because he's somebody actually
doing what the FAA says to do.
The other thing about glass cockpits
that I do like is it's great for night
flying, because the illumination is very uniform.
So one problem with steam gauges is that, at night,
some of the instruments can be dimmer or brighter
than the others.
I actually had a Diamond Star, a DA40--
and the attitude indicator--
which is the thing that you want to be using--
was the dimmest instrument in the panel.
And that was very annoying.
They were back-lit-- the instruments
themselves had the lights in there.
So there was really no way to adjust it.
I think you're going to find that glass panel is what's
in almost every aircraft within five or 10 years,
because it's just getting too expensive to maintain
these mechanical gyros.
If you send out a mechanical attitude indicator
to be overhauled, that's $2,000.
And the glass cockpit replacement
might only be $3,000 or $4,000.
And you'll never have to touch it again.
TINA SRISVASTAVA: When we polled earlier
in terms of people who've gone flying before--
so I'm going to ask three things.
Did you fly in a steam gauge airplane?
Did you find in a G1000, or glass cockpit?
Or have you flown in both?
So, steam gauge.
About half of you.
And then G1000, or glass cockpit.
Oh, only two or three.
And then if you've done both.
Only a handful.
So actually, it looks like the--
well, and of course, there are a bunch of you
that haven't flown at all.
But the ones that have, it looks like primarily
in the steam gauges.
So that's good to know.
AUDIENCE: 30 years ago, they hadn't been invented.
TINA SRISVASTAVA: 30 years ago, they hadn't been invented.
All right, that's true.
Well, this was great.
And Philip talked a little bit about night flying.
We're going to have a whole section on night
flying tomorrow.
But now we're going to do a break for lunch.
We'll give you about 45 minutes to get food.
Please come back a little bit before the hour and we'll
get started right at 1 o'clock.
Thanks.