17.486 | Fall 2016 | Graduate

Japan and East Asian Security

Assignments

A précis is not a critique or review of a longer work. It is a very concise summary of that longer piece of work. It is an abridged statement of the argument and evidence provided by the author. It is difficult to write because you must distill the essence of a longer (and often very complex argument) without injecting your own judgment about the strengths and weaknesses of the original.

The précis (2 pages) is to be written on at least one of the books marked by an asterisk (*) in the Readings table.

We will assign the books for each student collectively. Please be sure to send copies to both the instructor and to each student in the seminar. With the exception of readings for the first three sessions, all précis are due on the day the reading is assigned or suggested. Those from the first three sessions must be submitted by Session 4.

Student Example

“Précis: The Pursuit of Power.” (PDF)

This example appears courtesy of a MIT student and is anonymous by request.

Session 10: U.S. - Japan Bilateral Topics

  • The US-Japan Military Alliance
  • Extended Deterrence
  • Weapons Co-development, Co-Production, and Dual-Use Technology Transfer
  • Bilateral Trade and Investment

Session 11: Regional Topics

  • Regional Trade and Investment
  • New Security Architecture
  • Japanese Military Build-up
  • Japan and the Korean Peninsula
  • Sino-Japanese Relations
  • Russo-Japanese Relations
  • Japan-ASEAN Relations

Session 12: Global Topics

  • Japan and Terrorism
  • Global Warming
  • Collective Security
  • Japan and Maritime Security
  • Japan and the United Nations
  • Japan and International Organizations (World Bank, United Nations, WTO, IMF, OECD, etc.)
  • Global Treaties

Each student will prepare his / her own briefing on a single topic, selected from the list above. Each briefing will be organized according to the following outline:

  1. Generic Context (What is this a case of? Alliance dynamics, Regional integration, etc.)
  2. Analytics
    1. Domestic politics
    2. International system
    3. International sources of domestic politics
    4. Domestic sources of international politics
  3. Link analysis to two or more of the following Japanese postures:
    1. Status quo (Japan as junior partner)
    2. Collective security in Northeast Asia
    3. Japan as an independent regional power
    4. Japan as an independent global power.

These briefings will require significant research and synthesis, but should be no more than 25 double-spaced pages in length. Each student will brief the class for 20 minutes. The papers are due within one week after the day of the presentation.

Imagine that you are a historian writing in the year 2050 explaining how the world / region arrived at one of the following outcomes:

  • A Northeast Asia Collective Security Regime
  • Japan as Junior Partner to U.S. (status quo 2016)
  • Japan as Junior Partner to China
  • Japan as Independent Middle Power
  • Japan as Independent Global Power

Be sure to assess the international, domestic political, national security, economic, and technological developments of the previous 4 decades (2010s–2040s) in developing your analysis. Argue plausibly how this outcome was obtained, using the class readings—both narrative and theoretical—and relevant baseline data you collect.

These papers should not exceed 10 pages in length. To help your scenario building, you might read:

Tetlock, Philip E., and Aaron Belkin. “Counterfactual Thought Experiments in World Politics: Logical, Methodological, and Psychological Perspectives.” Chapter 1 in Counterfactual Thought Experiments in World Politics. Princeton University Press, 1996. ISBN: 9780691027913. [Preview with Google Books]

Think outside the box!!!

This paper is due during Session 7.

Student Example

“East-Asia in 2050.” (PDF)

This example appears courtesy of a MIT student and is anonymous by request.

Course Info

Departments
As Taught In
Fall 2016
Level