8.421 | Spring 2014 | Graduate

Atomic and Optical Physics I

Instructor Insights

Using a Tablet During Lectures

In this section, Professor Ketterle discusses how he uses a tablet computer during lectures.

Using the Tablet in the Same Way as a Blackboard

I use a tablet computer, as opposed to a blackboard, to communicate my notes during lectures. I find this medium works very well.

I try to use the tablet in the same way I would use a blackboard: to write things down step-by-step as I explain them. I want to use the tablet to document what is discussed in class; I do not want to use the computer to overwhelm students with rapid-fire slide presentations or to cover more material. That is very important to me.

"I try to use the tablet in the same way I would use a blackboard: to write things down step-by-step as I explain them. I want to use the tablet to document what is discussed in class; I do not want to use the computer to overwhelm students with rapid-fire slide presentations or to cover more material. That is very important tome."
—Wolfgang Ketterle

Advantages and Disadvantages of Using a Tablet

There are some advantages and disadvantages of using a tablet. With a tablet, you have less space on the screen, so you can write something, but then you have to scroll down, whereas in a large lecture hall, you may have multiple blackboards and, as a result, there may be more of the lecture visible to students. So that’s one advantage of using a blackboard.

However, with a tablet, I can scroll back and forth. At the end of a typical lecture, I probably would have erased the blackboards at least twice. If I want to remind students of a particular point, and that point has been erased, its visual impact is lost. A tablet allows me to easily return to text I composed at the beginning of the lecture.

Also, when I begin a lecture, I often use the tablet write-up from the previous class to summarize where we ended the class before diving into the new material. I would never have an un-erased blackboard from the previous lecture in a classroom! So, for me, this is a major advantage of using a tablet.

A tablet also allows me to post the notes immediately after class. Students understand that they do not need to copy from the board because everything I write down during the lecture is available to the students the same afternoon.

One advantage of the blackboard, in terms of addressing the class, is that I stand while I’m writing on it. I walk around. I’m more engaged. However, when you write on a blackboard, your back is to the students. With the tablet, I’m sitting most of the time (which is a minus), but I’m facing the class. I’m very deliberate when using the tablet; after I write something, I stand up to explain the concepts. I walk around the classroom, using a pointer to point to the equation I’ve written down.

Finally, the tablet has the advantage of allowing me to show how phenomena I derive have been observed in the laboratory. With a few clicks I can paste a figure from an original publication into the lecture transcript.

Using the Tablet to Allocate Time Wisely

Although I don’t want to use the tablet to speed things up, I do sometimes make a judgment call. If I feel a derivation has too many steps and is too lengthy, and the graduate students—who are quite experienced and have already seen a lot of derivations in the undergraduate courses—would better understand it if they worked the problem at home, then I sometimes use a pre-written slide featuring the whole derivation. Instead of spending time writing down the derivation, I point out its simple mathematical transformations. In this way, using pre-written slides allows me to show students many equations without going into details.

All in all, using the tablet has been a positive experience. Students seem to like it, as well. I sometimes ask students—especially at the beginning of the course—if they would prefer the tablet or the blackboard—and the majority want me to continue using the tablet.

Course Info

Departments
As Taught In
Spring 2014
Level
Learning Resource Types
Lecture Videos
Problem Sets
Exams
Instructor Insights